"If the Friends of the Fox Point Pool raise $3.3 million for the construction of a new pool, the Village will move forward with the project." That sentence comes from the Village Manager's weekly summary of the Oct. 13 Village Board meeting. For three summers, nobody could say whether Fox Point would get a pool back on Santa Monica Boulevard. That question now has a dollar figure and a date attached. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported that the same resolution set a deadline of Feb. 1, 2030, and described fundraising as stalled before the Board acted.
The Board didn't fold the pool into the capital budget, and it didn't send it to voters. It made the private campaign the deciding factor and gave that campaign a smaller target.
How the Village Got Here
The old municipal pool opened in 1968. In June 2023 the Village announced it would not open that season. Replacement valves had arrived in the wrong size, the right ones were no longer made, and staff estimated that rebuilding the pit-area plumbing would cost at least another $25,000 to $30,000 for maybe two or three weeks of swimming. The Friends of the Fox Point Pool started raising money in June 2024. The Village Board unanimously approved a schematic design in April 2024. Demolition of the old pool started April 2, 2025, the Journal Sentinel reported at the time.
Under the original arrangement, the Friends would raise $4 million privately, which they described as about half the estimated project cost. In June 2025, North Shore Living Magazine coverage posted on the Friends' media page reported more than $130,000 pledged or donated by more than 130 families, with support from a Tate Family Foundation grant. That figure is more than a year old, but it shows how far the campaign was from $4 million.
What Actually Changed on Oct. 13
The reduction came out of the Board's Sept. 8 meeting. There, staff presented a report on pool memberships, revenues and expenses, reconstruction costs and possible partnerships. Afterward the Board directed staff to rewrite the agreement so the Friends' 50 percent match would apply only to pool-related expenses. The cut came from how the costs were sorted.
| Item | Before | After Oct. 13 |
|---|---|---|
| Friends' required contribution | $4.0 million | $3.3 million |
| What the 50% match covers | Whole project | Pool-related costs only |
| Fundraising deadline | None | Feb. 1, 2030 |
| Village commitment | Tied to the original agreement | Proceed if $3.3 million is raised |
The staff presentation spells out the reallocation. Treating the community center as its own cost lowers the "pool cost" by $1,052,360. Removing demolition costs, now that the old pool is gone, lowers the estimate by another $180,000. The underlying figures come from a March 2024 estimate by Parkitecture. That estimate put the full project at $7,090,780, within a range of $6,736,241 to $7,799,858, not counting parking-lot improvements. According to staff, Parkitecture considers those ranges still valid for conceptual discussion, about two and a half years after they were drawn up.
Why Construction Money Has to Come From Donors
The Sept. 8 presentation shows two problems with paying for the pool through the Village budget.
The first is operating cost. In 2022, the old pool's last season, it brought in $65,617 in membership revenue and $99,135 in total revenue against $205,755 in expenses, for a net loss of $106,620. From 2014 through 2022, revenue fell 34 percent while expenses rose 5 percent, and total net losses came to $842,025. The membership numbers explain much of that. Total membership fell 15 percent over those years because nonresident memberships dropped by half. Resident memberships actually rose 19 percent over the same period.
The second is competition for capital money. At the same Sept. 8 meeting, staff presented a 2027–2031 capital improvements plan with $80.4 million in needed work on sewer, water, roads and facilities. The recommended 2027 budget includes $7.7 million to rebuild Santa Monica Boulevard from Green Tree Road to Bradley Road, and the Village Manager has warned that these projects will likely mean higher utility rates in future years. The full pool estimate is close to the cost of that single road project.
Outside help for construction didn't turn up either. None of the North Shore communities wanted a capital or operating partnership, citing competing capital needs, tight operating budgets and little demand from their own residents. Staff added that competitive grants would be a tough case to make unless the project is shovel-ready.
There was one useful finding. The Jewish Community Center and the Nicolet High School Rec program both expressed interest in helping operate a pool, which staff said could reduce the levy support needed each year. That leaves construction as the open question, and construction is exactly what the Friends' $3.3 million would cover.
The Paths the Board Didn't Take
The presentation listed several alternatives. Apart from changing nothing, the Board could have:
- Rescinded the existing resolution and put a new pool in the 2027 capital improvements budget.
- Rescinded it and decided not to pursue a pool for now.
- Rescinded it and set the fundraising target at 50 percent of pool-only costs, with a deadline.
- Rescinded it and considered a binding or nonbinding referendum on building a new pool.
The Board chose the third option. The Sept. 8 staff presentation also noted that the Village doesn't need a referendum to issue debt for a pool. It listed referendums as an option: a nonbinding question, a binding levy increase to cover debt payments, or a binding levy increase to cover yearly operating shortfalls. For now, none of those is on the table. Whether construction goes ahead depends on what donors give over the next three years and three months. You can watch the full Sept. 8 discussion in the Village Board meeting recording, and the Oct. 13 meeting is posted on the Village's CivicClerk portal.
What the Money Would Build
The Friends say the new pool would go on the current site on Santa Monica Boulevard. The 2024 schematic concept includes:
- A zero-depth entry, six lap lanes and a diving board
- Roughly 6,760 square feet of water, with capacity for about 387 swimmers
- A building of about 3,200 square feet, plus a 1,000-square-foot community room as an add-on
- Shade structures, concessions seating and an outdoor beer-garden area
- Accessible restrooms and possible relocation of the playground
The community room's cost was moved out of the "pool cost" to reach the $3.3 million figure, which raises a question for 2027 and beyond. The Oct. 13 resolution doesn't say how that room would be paid for.
The regional comparison matters too. In its list of local government pools, the staff presentation shows Mequon's expected to open in 2027. It also says Milwaukee County's strategic plan replaces smaller neighborhood pools with larger regional aquatic centers. Fox Point is trying to rebuild a village-scale pool while the county moves toward fewer, bigger facilities. That makes the 2030 deadline a real test of how much residents want to keep one close to home.
How to Give or Get Involved
The Friends accept one-time and recurring donations online through their donation page, along with online pledges and mailed checks to Friends of the Fox Point Pool, P.O. Box 170234, Milwaukee, WI 53217-4505. They can be reached at [email protected]. Their home page lists other ways to help, including newsletter signup, volunteering, yard signs, a lemonade-stand challenge, talking to neighbors and offering professional skills or connections. Some of their pages still list the earlier $4 million goal, so for the current figure, go by the Village's Oct. 13 resolution.
Recreation Arriving Without a Capital Line
While the pool waits on donors, other recreation changes in Fox Point are coming through permits rather than big capital projects. In July the Board approved a conditional use permit allowing pickleball during limited hours at Longacre and Indian Creek parks, and told staff to add court lines and signs posting the hours and rules. The June draft proposed 9 a.m. to noon at Longacre and 4 to 7 p.m. at Indian Creek. Check the posted signs at the courts for the final schedule.
At the same Oct. 13 meeting that reset the pool target, the Board approved The Porticos on Bradley Road converting two tennis courts to pickleball. It also approved a Play It Again Sports store at RiverPoint. That's the same shopping center where Donut Zone held its ribbon cutting Aug. 27. The center sits at 8687 N. Port Washington Road. None of these needed a referendum or a spot in the $80.4 million plan. The pool's construction depends on the Friends reaching $3.3 million by Feb. 1, 2030.
Community amenities like a neighborhood pool are part of what makes a place feel like home, and they're part of how we talk with clients about life on the North Shore. If you'd like to know how Fox Point's park and recreation plans might figure into your plans for your own home, the Kurtin Realty team would be glad to talk it through. Request Your Free Home Valuation.